Pricey President Biden:
In October 1973, the armies of Egypt and Syria launched a shock pincer assault on Israel. Because the Israeli Military fell low on ammunition, your predecessor Richard Nixon ordered an enormous airlift of weaponry that helped to save lots of the one Jewish democracy from being destroyed from the surface.
Fifty years later, Mr. President, this Jewish democracy urgently wants one other airlift to reserve it from being destroyed from the within. It wants an pressing resupply of exhausting truths — one thing solely you possibly can present.
And what are these truths? That if Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu continues making an attempt to ram via a invoice that will strip Israel’s Supreme Courtroom of its most essential authorized authority — to examine excessive appointments or choices of Israel’s political echelon — and accomplish that and not using a semblance of nationwide consensus, it’s going to fracture Israel’s army and undermine not solely shared values between the U.S. and Israel but in addition important U.S. pursuits.
Mr. President, once we met last Tuesday and also you gave me your very measured assertion urging Netanyahu to not “rush” this laws via with out “the broadest doable consensus” — which he so clearly doesn’t have — it got here as an electrical shock to the Israeli political system, dominating the information for a number of days.
It was such a shock as a result of a overwhelming majority of Israelis imagine — rightly — that you’re a true good friend and that your recommendation got here from the guts.
However I’m afraid this Israeli authorities wants one other dose of your powerful love — not simply out of your coronary heart however from the guts of U.S. strategic pursuits as nicely.
As a result of Netanyahu is plowing forward regardless of your urgings. Regardless of a warning from greater than 1,100 Israeli Air Power pilots and technicians that they won’t fly for a dictatorship. Regardless of an open letter signed by dozens of former prime safety officers, together with former heads of the Israel Protection Forces, Mossad, Shin Guess and police beseeching the prime minister to cease. Regardless of Israel’s prime enterprise discussion board warning of “irreversible and destructive consequences on the Israeli economy.” Regardless of fears that this might ultimately fracture unit cohesion within the base of the Israeli Military. And regardless of a outstanding, largely spontaneous five-day march by on a regular basis Israelis from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem, the likes of which had by no means occurred earlier than.
If I could counsel, Mr. President, what is required is that your secretary of state, your secretary of protection, your Treasury secretary, your commerce secretary, your secretary of agriculture, your U.S. commerce consultant, your legal professional normal, your C.I.A. director and your Joint Chiefs name their Israeli counterparts right this moment and allow them to know that if Netanyahu strikes forward — and not using a consensus, fracturing Israeli society and its army — it won’t solely undermine the shared values between our two nations but in addition do critical harm to our personal strategic pursuits within the Center East.
And U.S. pursuits are very a lot our enterprise. As a result of because the Knesset strikes to vote on this situation on Monday, one thing crucial may break in Israel and in our relationship with Israel. And as soon as it’s gone, it’s going to by no means come again.
I hope that it isn’t already too late.
What American pursuits are at stake? It needs to be apparent to each U.S. policymaker by now that Netanyahu’s cupboard, one that you simply described as one of the crucial “excessive” you’ve ever encountered, has its thoughts set on two dismantling initiatives.
One is to dismantle the ability of the Supreme Courtroom to rein on this authorities’s excessive agenda, and the opposite is to dismantle the Oslo peace course of and its highway map for a two-state answer, with the intention to pave the way in which for a unilateral Israeli annexation of the West Financial institution. Oslo has been a cornerstone of America’s Center East coverage since 1993.
These twin dismantlings are interconnected: the Jewish supremacists in Netanyahu’s cupboard have to get the Supreme Courtroom out of the way in which with the intention to perform their plans to annex the West Financial institution. Such a transfer may simply destabilize Jordan, as it might seemingly push increasingly Palestinians there and alter its fragile demographic stability. Jordan is an important buffer state within the area for the U.S., which operates from Jordanian territory, in collaboration with Jordan, to take care of U.S. safety threats from Syria and western Iraq, the place ISIS forces proceed to function.
On the identical time, Mr. President, you’re wrestling with one of many greatest choices ever involving U.S. technique within the Center East: whether or not to fulfill Saudi Arabia’s requests for a proper safety assure from America, for a U.S.-overseen civilian nuclear program and for entry to a number of the most superior U.S. arms. In return for this, Saudi Arabia would normalize its relations with Israel (supplied that Israel makes some concessions to the Palestinians) and restrict its collaboration with China.
It might be each tough and unlucky to get such a deal via Congress with out robust help from Democrats within the Senate. As you realize, Mr. President, Netanyahu and Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman are two of the least common world leaders amongst progressive Democrats, particularly contemplating the way in which Netanyahu, over the previous decade, moved to make help for Israel a Republican trigger and spurned the embrace of secular American Jews for that of Christian evangelicals as an alternative.
In brief, profitable sufficient help amongst Democrats to forge this complicated take care of Saudi Arabia can be an enormous elevate on day; will probably be even tougher if Netanyahu neuters the Israeli Supreme Courtroom — undermining our shared values of an unbiased judiciary — and strikes forward with plans to annex the West Financial institution. And with out you as president, such a deal could be just about not possible, as a result of only a few Democrats within the Senate would help it if it was pushed by a Republican president. In brief, the window for this deal is small.
Furthermore, in 2016 you and President Barack Obama signed a 10-year, $38 billion settlement to reinforce Israel’s army. Are we supposed to simply sit again and watch silently whereas that army — which we now have made such an enormous funding in to amplify our energy projection within the Center East — fractures over efforts to limit the ability of the Israeli Supreme Courtroom? That will be a catastrophe for us and for Israel, which has actual enemies like Iran and Hezbollah on its doorstep.
Additionally, we are able to already see that the acute habits of this Israeli authorities in increasing settlements within the West Financial institution is starting to break the historic relations solid by President Donald Trump between Israel and the U.A.E., Bahrain and Morocco with the Abraham Accords. All three Arab nations have been pressured to chill their diplomatic ties with Israel.
Mr. President, there is no such thing as a establishment in any democracy that may’t be improved, and that applies to Israel’s Supreme Courtroom. There have been complaints from the middle proper that the Israeli excessive court docket manifested an occasional judicial overreach up to now. However between 2015 and 2019, Likud governments successfully shepherded the appointments of 4 conservative justices to the Supreme Courtroom — below the present system that Netanyahu desires to scrap. It exhibits you the way bogus this entire “judicial reform” actually is.
There’s a big distinction between making the Israeli Supreme Courtroom extra politically and ethnically inclusive and making this Israeli authorities immune from its scrutiny — particularly in a system by which the excessive court docket in Israel is the one actual examine on govt overreach.
And the latter is what Netanyahu’s coalition is as much as, and it’s the latter that undermines not simply our shared values with Israel but in addition our personal strategic pursuits, which we’re entitled — certainly we’re required — to defend.